top of page

The Saints Who Weren't Supposed to Be There: Bastien-Lepage's Joan of Arc

5 minutes ago
5 min read

A girl who has just stood up too fast


Something has happened a second before we arrived. A young woman in a faded blouse and brown skirt is on her feet in a scruffy garden, her body tilted forward, one arm stretched out to grip a branch as if the ground has shifted under her. Behind her, a wooden stool lies on its side next to the frame of a spinning wheel. Her eyes are wide, pale and fixed on nothing we can see.



This is Joan of Arc, painted by Jules Bastien-Lepage in 1879. It hangs today in Gallery 827 of the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York, and it is enormous: roughly two and a half metres high and almost three metres wide. Yet nothing in it is grand. There is no armour, no banner, no battlefield. Just a peasant teenager, some cabbages and weeds, a modest house, and a moment that is about to change her life and her country's history.


The painter from Lorraine


Bastien-Lepage was born in 1848 in Damvillers, a village in the Meuse region of Lorraine, and he died in Paris in 1884 at just 36. In that short career he became one of the leading voices of Naturalism, a style that took the outdoor light and ordinary rural people of the Realists and rendered them with almost photographic exactness.


Self-Portrait, c. 1880
Self-Portrait, c. 1880

His choice of Joan was not a neutral one. After France's defeat in the Franco-Prussian War of 1870–71, part of Lorraine was ceded to the new German Empire. Joan, a farm girl from Domrémy in the same region, suddenly became a symbol of a wounded nation's hopes, and paintings and statues of her poured into the Paris Salons. For an artist from Lorraine, she was also a neighbour. Bastien-Lepage visited Domrémy while preparing the picture, and the garden he painted is thought to be based on his own family's home in Damvillers.


Reading the garden


Start at the bottom of the canvas, because that is where Bastien-Lepage spent his patience. The foreground is crowded with leaves, stalks and grass rendered almost blade by blade. It feels damp and real, the sort of patch you could smell. Joan stands barefoot in it, and if you look closely her toes are curled tight into the ground. The Met's own catalogue notes that this clenched foot gives away the tension running through her whole body.


Then follow the objects. The toppled stool and the abandoned spinning apparatus tell the story without words: she was working, she heard something, she rose so suddenly that the seat went over. It is a domestic detail doing the job a trumpet blast or a beam of heavenly light would have done in an older history painting.

Her hand on the branch matters too. She is not reaching towards heaven in a theatrical gesture; she is steadying herself. It is the instinctive movement of someone who feels faint, and it makes the experience physical rather than symbolic. The vision is happening to her body.


Three ghosts among the apple trees


Now look up and to the left. Hovering among the trees, so faint you can miss them on first viewing, are three figures: the archangel Michael in armour, and Saints Margaret and Catherine. They are painted thinly, almost transparent, as if the garden is showing through them. Michael's form is barely more than a shimmer of metal and gold.


Crucially, Joan is not looking at them. They are behind her, and her gaze runs forward and up, out of the picture. She hears rather than sees. The saints are there for us, the viewers, so that we know what she is experiencing.


According to the Met, the composition went through several versions, from a conventional scene of Joan kneeling at an altar to the girl at her spinning wheel and finally to this arrangement. The artist reportedly argued with his friend and biographer André Theuriet over whether the saints should appear at all, and one early account claims he enlarged the canvas to make room for them.




Why Paris was split


When the painting was shown at the Salon of 1880, critics largely agreed on one thing: Joan herself was superb. Her pose and expression were praised as a convincing picture of a spiritual awakening. Bastien-Lepage himself had written to a friend that he believed he had found "the head of my Joan of Arc," a face that combined resolve with a simple country charm. The model has been identified as his cousin, Marie-Adèle Robert, who sat for him on other occasions.


The trouble was everything around her. Some reviewers found the foliage so busy that it fought the figure for attention. And the saints seemed to break the rules of the very style Bastien-Lepage was famous for. How could a painter who promised to show the world exactly as it looked include floating, see-through visitors from heaven? The novelist and critic Joris-Karl Huysmans summed up the complaint by calling it "false naturalism."


Accounts say the reception stung enough that Bastien-Lepage left Paris for London for a time, setting aside a planned painting of Ophelia in a similar vein. The young painter and diarist Marie Bashkirtseff, a devoted admirer, fumed in her journal that French critics had failed to appreciate a picture that was adored in America.


A flaw that became the point


Here is the irony: the feature critics attacked is exactly what makes the painting unforgettable today. Bastien-Lepage had a problem no camera could solve. How do you paint an inner voice? His answer was to render the real world with total conviction and then let the supernatural seep in, faint and uncertain, like breath on glass. The saints are not solid because Joan's experience is not something the rest of the world can verify. We are left suspended, as she is, between a damp French garden and something else entirely.


The picture's later life was American. After the Salon, it was bought by the New York businessman Erwin Davis, who gave it to the Metropolitan Museum in 1889. That same year it travelled back to Paris for the Exposition Universelle, a final homecoming before settling permanently in New York.


How to look at it in person


If you visit, stand back first and let Joan's face hold you; it is the hook the painter intended. Then walk closer and lower your eyes to the weeds, the stool, the curled toes. Finally, step to the left and search the trees for the saints. They reveal themselves slowly, which may be the most truthful thing about the painting. Visions, after all, rarely arrive all at once.

 
 
bottom of page